Platform lighting: LED vs. metal halide

 

Recently the LED technology It has undergone great development due to the investments made by lighting companies to combat the technical deficiencies it presented in its early days. This fact, together with the international trend towards creating more energy-efficient airports It makes us question the following: Is LED lighting really advantageous? Its application in public lighting is well known, but what about the platforms at airports where projectors are installed at a height of 25 m? Do they provide enough luminous flux to compete with traditional metal halides? Does the energy savings they provide over their lifetime compensate for the installation cost?

To answer these questions and extract meaningful data, we take a platform from a real airport and design the lighting with metal halide and LED projectors, taking into account the requirements described in Part 4 of OACI's Aerodrome Design Manual document 9157 for both options.

LED-vs-HM-ES02The selected luminaires have symmetrical photometry, belong to the same commercial house and have the technical characteristics shown in the following table:

 

After performing a photometric study of the platform with both projectors, we concluded that:

  • The total installed power in the case of metal halide projectors is 176 kW, however in the case of LEDs this value is 73.74 kW. If we also take into account the losses due to the ballasts, we obtain that the solution with LED luminaires consume 58% less. This reduction in installed power represents a direct savings in the airport's electrical installation in terms of wiring, protection and emergency supplies.
  • According to the lifespan of lamps, ballasts, projectors, and considering that the airport operates 24 hours a day, it is inferred that the metal halide lamps will be replaced every two or three years, while the LED projectors will be replaced every 23 years.
  • LED projectors present a luminous efficiency 38.8% higher that the metal halide projectors.
  • LED luminaires provide a instantaneous ignition.This eliminates the time-consuming process of waiting for the lamp to reach the proper temperature.

However, if we analyze the initial cost of LED projectors as an investment compared to the cost of metal halide projectors, taking into account annual maintenance and energy consumption as cash flows, we obtain a TIR of 19% and they come to $536,000, considering the required rate of return as the price of the 30-year US bond.

Therefore, if LED lighting saves on maintenance and energy consumption, which translates into an investment with a return on investment of 19%, providing the same levels of illumination, the question that would have to be asked is… Why hasn’t their airport already installed LED platform lighting?

 

cabecera-307web-02

 

Share

More topical issues

Portaviones
17/11/2026

The first aircraft carrier

Micromissile FOX
13/11/2026

AERTEC is making progress with the validation of the FOX micro-missile, designed for drones

SAETA II program
05/11/2026

AERTEC will develop the Remote Interface Unit (RIU) for the SAETA II program

Zephyr HAPS
27/10/2026

AERTEC and AALTO are joining forces to drive the future of stratospheric aviation

Airbus A300
20/10/2026

The Airbus A300 and the flight that changed the course of European aviation

Access to restricted airport areas
13/10/2026

Airport security: access to restricted areas

Contact